The Midway Goes Still

A flower-decorated carousel horse, a small wooden wheel, and a blue coat left hanging beside the fair

ARCHIVE / PLATE 01 · THE DAY THE FAIR OPENED

THE FIRST TURN01 / 05

The first promise.

The girl had two pennies, a blue coat too large for her and a grandmother’s warning she was trying very hard to forget. The boy had been staring at the carousel for an hour. When she caught him looking at the white horse with painted daisies, he said, too quickly, “I wasn’t frightened.” She told him she was, a little. That made it easier for him to admit the same.

They bought a ticket stamped ADMIT TWO. She chose the white horse with painted daisies. Beside it stood a black horse wearing a blue rein, and the boy chose that one. With her penny she scratched two little marks beneath a painted daisy. Then she pulled a narrow thread from the cuff of her blue coat and knotted it around the black horse’s blue rein. “So we’ll know which ones are ours,” she said. He touched the knot as though it were a promise worth keeping. Whatever happened, they would meet at the gate.

The organ began, warm and grand. Beyond the turning horses, people laughed with their mouths open. The boy reached across the brass pole and almost caught her hand. Above the music came five small flute notes. They played once, then again, a little nearer. On the second circuit, the gate had moved. On the third, the laughing people were perfectly still. A woman held a fallen apple in midair.

The girl called to the boy. He answered, but the carousel was suddenly wider than before. Between them stood rows of horses that had not been there a moment earlier. Far below, under the boards, something wet shifted in its sleep.

“When it stops, you’ll still be here, won’t you?”

He nodded. She almost saw him answer. Then the platform turned, and the space between their horses grew wider than the fair itself.

02

The Puppeteer beside a weathered carousel horse, holding the only key while his reflection watches from a spotted mirror

ARCHIVE / PLATE 02 · THE KEEPER AND THE KEY

THE SECOND TURN02 / 05

The horse facing the wall.

The keeper came to them in white gloves, carrying a silver flute and the only key to the gate. “Bonsoir, mes petits.” He spoke gently, the way grown-ups do when they have already decided what a child should feel. He told the girl she would be safer on the horse turned toward the wall. He told the boy that she had asked to ride alone.

At first he took almost nothing. A penny. The smell of apples. Which direction the gate had been. Then he took the moment they had made their promise and put a different memory in its place. The girl remembered the boy laughing when she was afraid. The boy remembered her saying she wished he had never come. Neither memory had happened, but each one hurt exactly as though it had.

The girl’s horse faced peeling plaster. Its painted mane was damp beneath her fingers. Beyond the rails a pale, riderless horse stood in the mist, white as a warning no one wanted to read. From the other side of the wall she heard the boy calling, then heard his voice say, “I don’t know her.” It sounded real enough to break something in her chest. She pressed her forehead to the cold wood and tried to remember the last kind thing he had said.

The boy passed an empty saddle with her blue coat hanging from its pole. The keeper told him she had left. He almost believed him. Then the carousel brought him alongside the black horse, and his fingers found the knot on its blue rein. He could not recall who tied it. He only knew it had been tied for someone to find. Why would a girl who meant to leave have left him a way back?

“Why do I feel sorry for something I can’t remember doing?”

The keeper smiled. He had not moved their horses. He had changed what each child believed about the other.

04

The boy on the carousel, looking over his shoulder with an Admit Two ticket tucked into his waistcoat

ARCHIVE / PLATE 03 · THE BOY / BORROWED WORDS

THE THIRD TURN03 / 05

A mouth full of borrowed words.

The flute played five notes, paused, and began again. After enough turns, the children could no longer tell which thoughts were theirs. Above the manège, the lamps drifted loose from their wires like wandering feux follets. On his table the keeper kept two gilded horses with a bright blue ribbon across them—a beautiful copy of something real. The girl could not explain why the ribbon looked wrong. Inside his coat were old tickets, each written in a familiar hand: I enjoyed myself. I wanted to stay. No one made me.

He placed a ticket in the boy’s palm. The boy tried to say, “Let me out.” His mouth said, “Thank you for having me.” The words arrived in his own voice, smooth and cheerful. He bit the inside of his cheek to stop them. The metallic taste was the first thing he had felt that the Puppeteer had not given him.

The girl was taught to wave to the audience every time she passed. Her arm lifted before she wanted it to. She smiled while tears ran into her collar. She began to fear that the smiling girl was the real one and the frightened girl only a mistake. Then she saw two faint scratches beneath a painted daisy. She did not remember making them, but her hand knew the movement: one mark for her, one for him.

She could not remember the boy’s face. He could not remember the sound of her laugh. But whenever the carousel passed the wall, both felt the same sudden grief. He folded the false ticket until the paper split. In its centre, beneath the new words, the old stamp remained: ADMIT TWO.

“If I wanted to stay, why do you keep the key?”

The keeper raised his flute. On the torn ticket, beneath all his borrowed words, the old stamp still read ADMIT TWO.

06

The black carousel horse with its blue rein, the one clue the Puppeteer could never change

PLATE 04 · BLACK HORSE / BLUE REIN

THE FOURTH TURN04 / 05

The blue rein remembers.

Beyond the painted horses stood the black horse with the blue rein. The girl saw a small knot worked into its leather, the thread she had pulled from her coat before the flute began. Faces, names and promises could be rearranged. The black horse remained black. The rein remained blue. And the knot had not moved. The Puppeteer could change what they remembered, but not what their hands had done.

She caught the blue rein. The boards tilted beneath her, and for a moment she was back at the beginning: two pennies in her palm, a boy who could admit he was frightened only after she had said it first. She remembered choosing the white daisy horse and seeing him climb onto the black one beside it. What came back was not his name or even his face. It was the relief of not being afraid alone.

Across the turning platform, the boy heard her call. He had walked through so many false memories that he no longer trusted the name forming in his mouth. Then he saw her lift an open hand, palm up, as if showing him two pennies. His own hand rose before he knew why. The carousel drew them apart again. “I’m still here,” he called. The keeper whispered that she had abandoned him. The boy looked at the knot on the black horse’s blue rein and kept moving toward her.

“Reste avec moi,” he called—the French words he had learned under the fair’s lamps. Stay with me. She answered with the Gaelic her grandmother had spoken in the kitchen: “Fuirich còmhla rium.” Stay with me. They could not reach each other yet. But the two languages crossed the space the Puppeteer had built between them.

“You don’t have to remember my name. Remember that I was here.”

The blue rein loosened. For the first time in all those turns, the keeper played only four notes.

08

The girl in her blue coat and the boy reach toward each other from neighboring carousel horses while the ride blurs between them

ARCHIVE / PLATE 05 · THE HAND THAT REMEMBERED

THE FIFTH TURN05 / 05

When the midway went still.

The fifth note would not come. The carousel slowed enough for them to hear what lay beyond the music: rain in the grass, an owl beyond the fence, and two frightened breaths. The boy found the girl at the edge of the platform. He knew he had crossed every turn to reach her, but he could not remember her name. She looked at him as if a stranger had brought back something she had buried. For one terrible moment neither moved. Then she opened her hand and showed him two pennies. He took one. He remembered a girl who had made it possible to admit he was afraid. Tears came before the memory did. She put her hand over his. They held on.

They told the keeper what he had done. They named the lies, one by one, even when their voices shook. The boy said he had not chosen to forget her. The girl said she had never asked to be left alone. Above them, the wandering lights trembled. Beneath the boards the black water struck the wood hard enough to shake the brass poles. Gold leaf peeled from the horses like dead skin.

The gate appeared. It was only a few steps away. The girl gripped the boy’s hand and felt him grip back. She was afraid. This time she let herself say so. “Me too,” he whispered—the first true thing he remembered telling her. They began to run. The keeper moved to block them, not with a shout, but with a wounded look, as though leaving him were an act of cruelty.

“Le manège garde ce qu’il aime,” he whispered. The carousel keeps what it loves. Then the children saw the key in his hand and understood what he called love. The girl turned toward him. Her voice was small, but it carried over the organ.

“You can’t call it play when I can’t get off. You can’t call it love when you lock the gate.”

The keeper found his fifth note. The gate folded into darkness. Two pennies warmed in the girl’s palm. She was on the white horse with the painted daisies again. Beside her waited the black horse, its blue rein hanging loose. A little knot was still tied there, although she could not remember making it. The boy studied the black horse as if it had been waiting for him. “Is this one taken?” he asked. She did not know why her throat tightened. She reached across the brass pole and held the rein steady for him. Somewhere below them, the old water held its breath.

10